By Muhammad Luqman
LAHORE, June 30 (INP-Wealth Pakistan) -- Punjab's decision to introduce algae-based "Liquid Trees" has generated optimism as an innovative approach to tackling urban air pollution, but environmental experts say the technology should be viewed as a complementary solution rather than a replacement for conventional tree planting.
The initiative comes as Lahore continues to grapple with worsening air pollution and recurring smog, while limited urban space and inadequate forest cover have prompted authorities to explore alternative technologies to improve air quality.
A Liquid Tree is a water-filled tank containing unicellular algae. A solar-powered pump pushes air into the tank, where the algae absorb carbon dioxide (CO₂) and release oxygen through photosynthesis, much like natural trees.
According to the Punjab Environment Protection Department (EPD), Pakistan's first Liquid Tree was tested in Faisalabad for several weeks before being installed in Lahore. Scientists evaluated more than 100 algae species collected from across the country before selecting the most effective variety for the project.
Speaking to Wealth Pakistan, Punjab EPD spokesman Sajid Bashir said the initial phase of the initiative envisages installing Liquid Trees at major shopping malls and in indoor and outdoor public spaces to help reduce urban air pollution.
"Following the success of the pilot project in Lahore, the Liquid Tree initiative may be replicated in other major cities, including Faisalabad, Rawalpindi and Multan," he said.
The technology was first demonstrated in Serbia's capital, Belgrade, in 2022. According to the original project, algae can absorb carbon dioxide 10 to 50 times faster than trees on an equal-size basis, while one Liquid Tree unit is said to provide the carbon absorption capacity of two mature trees. The project was developed by the University of Belgrade with support from the United Nations.
While officials view the technology as a useful addition to pollution-control efforts, climate experts say its greatest value lies in complementing — not replacing—conventional afforestation. They believe that5 Punjab's pilot project will provide valuable insights into the practical role that algae-based carbon capture can play in improving urban air quality. However, they maintain that expanding natural tree cover, protecting existing forests and promoting sustainable urban planning will remain the foundation of long-term environmental management.
"A Liquid Tree may process carbon dioxide faster in a small space, but a real tree provides far greater environmental benefits over its lifetime. It is therefore a supplement, not a substitute, for planting trees," said Nazifa Butt, Director of Climate Action and Sustainability at WWF-Pakistan.
Talking to Wealth Pakistan, she said natural trees provide shade, cool surrounding temperatures, absorb rainwater, improve soil health, provide habitats for birds and insects, and store carbon for decades — ecosystem services that algae tanks cannot deliver.
Nazifa Butt acknowledged that algae grow and multiply much faster than tree leaves, allowing them to process carbon dioxide more rapidly within a limited space. However, she cautioned that this advantage depends on strong sunlight, suitable algae species and favourable environmental conditions, meaning the performance of Liquid Trees can vary significantly.
Experts also questioned the cost-effectiveness of deploying the technology on a large scale.
"A Liquid Tree costs between US$10,000 and US$15,000 per unit to install, whereas planting a tree costs only a few hundred rupees per sapling," Nazifa Butt said.
She noted that the technology has so far been installed in Belgrade, Serbia, where it originated, as well as in Noida, India, and at a university in Bangladesh.
"There has been discussion about installing similar units in other Serbian cities, as well as in New York and Paris. However, these remain proposals rather than actual installations," she said.
Nazifa Butt added that a single unit offsets emissions equivalent to only a few mature trees, meaning that achieving a meaningful city-wide impact would require thousands of units along with continuous maintenance and operational funding.
She stressed that the long-term success of Liquid Tree technology depends on sustained financial support and regular maintenance.
"Without proper upkeep, the units gradually lose their effectiveness," she said.