ISLAMABAD: Pakistan's public debt faces six categories of economic and fiscal shocks that could undermine debt sustainability, with a combination of weaker economic growth, fiscal deterioration, higher interest rates and rupee depreciation potentially pushing public and publicly guaranteed debt to 75.2% of GDP by FY2027, according to a Finance Ministry assessment.

The Debt Sustainability Analysis Report FY2025–FY2027

identifies risks arising from deterioration in the federal primary balance, slower real GDP growth, higher interest rates, exchange rate depreciation, combined macro-fiscal pressures and financial-sector contingent liabilities.

Under the baseline scenario, the public and publicly guaranteed debt-to-GDP ratio was projected to decline from 70.4% in FY2024 to 68.6% in FY2025, 67.8% in FY2026 and 66.6% in FY2027. However, the report warns that adverse developments in fiscal and economic conditions could reverse this trajectory.

The assessment, prepared by the Finance Ministry's Economic Adviser's Wing using FY2024 data and assumptions, examines six categories of shocks through seven individual stress tests, including two variations of the federal primary balance shock.

The most severe outcome arises under the combined macro-fiscal shock, which assumes simultaneous deterioration in economic growth, the federal primary balance, interest rates and the exchange rate.

Under this scenario, the debt-to-GDP ratio rises to 73.5% in FY2026 and 75.2% in FY2027, exceeding the 70% debt sustainability benchmark used for emerging markets.

Gross financing needs under the combined shock are projected at 23.1% of GDP in FY2026 and 22.8% in FY2027, compared with baseline projections of 21.3% and 19.5%, respectively.

The second major risk involves deterioration in the federal primary balance, with the report examining two alternative scenarios.

A 50% reduction in the planned fiscal adjustment would increase the debt ratio to 69.4% by FY2027, while a return to the historical average federal primary deficit of 1.6% of GDP would push it to 73.1%.

The corresponding gross financing needs would reach 20.9% and 22.8% of GDP, respectively, against the baseline of 19.5%.

Under the real GDP growth shock, which assumes economic growth falls by one historical standard deviation for two consecutive years, the debt ratio would increase to 70.7% by FY2027, with gross financing needs reaching 21.1% of GDP.

The report also examines a 300-basis-point increase in nominal interest rates, which would raise the debt ratio to 68.1% by FY2027, compared with 66.6% under the baseline.

The Finance Ministry identifies the high proportion of floating-rate domestic debt as a significant vulnerability, as changes in interest rates directly affect government borrowing costs.

Under the exchange rate shock, which assumes a 15% depreciation of the rupee, the debt-to-GDP ratio would increase to 68.2% by FY2027, while gross financing needs would reach 20.1% of GDP.

The sixth category, a financial-sector contingent liability shock, assumes a one-time increase in non-interest expenditure equivalent to 10% of banking-sector assets, alongside weaker economic growth and deterioration in the primary balance.

This scenario would push the debt ratio to 72.8% of GDP by FY2027, with gross financing needs increasing to 21.6%.

The report warns that even under the baseline scenario, Pakistan's gross financing requirements remain elevated, limiting the government's capacity to absorb adverse economic developments.

Gross financing needs were projected at 25.4% of GDP in FY2025, declining to 21.3% in FY2026 and 19.5% in FY2027. All three figures exceed the 15% benchmark used in the assessment for emerging markets.

Pakistan's total public and publicly guaranteed debt stood at Rs74.63 trillion at the end of June 2024, compared with Rs66.40 trillion a year earlier, representing an increase of Rs8.23 trillion, or 12.41%.

Of the total, public debt amounted to Rs71.25 trillion, up from Rs62.88 trillion in June 2023, while publicly guaranteed debt declined from Rs3.52 trillion to Rs3.38 trillion.

Domestic public and publicly guaranteed debt increased by 20.26% to Rs48.62 trillion from Rs40.43 trillion, while external debt remained broadly unchanged at Rs26.01 trillion, compared with Rs25.97 trillion a year earlier.

Domestic obligations accounted for 65.2% of the total debt portfolio at the end of June 2024, with external obligations representing the remaining 34.8%.

The report identifies interest rate exposure as a major vulnerability in the domestic debt portfolio. As of December 2023, floating-rate instruments accounted for 74.6% of domestic public and publicly guaranteed debt, compared with 25.4% for fixed-rate instruments.

Long-term debt represented 68.6% of domestic obligations, while short-term instruments accounted for 31.4%.

Within the external debt portfolio, 65.4% carried fixed interest rates and 34.6% floating rates. Medium- to long-term obligations accounted for 81.1% of external debt, compared with 18.9% for short-term borrowing.

Multilateral lenders accounted for 55% of the external debt stock at the end of June 2024, followed by bilateral creditors at 29% and Eurobonds at 8%.

The Finance Ministry's baseline assumptions projected real GDP growth of 3.6% in FY2025, 4.8% in FY2026 and 5.5% in FY2027, compared with 2.4% in FY2024.

Average inflation was projected to decline from 23.4% in FY2024 to 12% in FY2025, 7.5% in FY2026 and 7% in FY2027.

The federal primary balance was projected at a surplus of 1.02% of GDP in FY2025, followed by 0.4% in FY2026 and 0.5% in FY2027.

The assessment attributes the decline in the debt ratio during FY2024, from 79% to 70.4%, to exchange rate stability, a federal primary surplus, economic recovery and lower real interest rates.

The Finance Ministry identifies fiscal consolidation, improved tax revenue mobilisation, expenditure management and longer domestic debt maturities as priorities for managing borrowing risks.

The report also recommends diversifying financing sources, smoothing repayment schedules, accessing concessional borrowing, tapping international capital markets and encouraging non-resident investment in government securities.