Image for: India's investment recovery remains uneven as foreign portfolio outflows persist

 

By Qudsia Bano


ISLAMABAD, Nov. 18 (INP-Wealth Pakistan) -- India's recovery in foreign direct investment remains uneven as persistent portfolio outflows and a sharp September reversal raise questions about whether stronger long-term capital inflows can translate into a sustained improvement in overall foreign investment.


The divergence highlights differing investor responses to India's economic prospects. While strategic investors continue to pursue longer-term opportunities, portfolio investors remain sensitive to market valuations, global interest rates and currency movements.


According to preliminary data from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), net direct investment into India reached $31 billion during April-September 2026, compared with $26.1 billion in the corresponding period of 2025. After accounting for outward direct investment, overall net FDI stood at $8.8 billion, up from $7.4 billion a year earlier.


However, September marked a setback, with net direct investment into India turning negative at -$0.5 billion and overall net FDI recording an outflow of $4.9 billion as Indian companies continued investing abroad.


Foreign portfolio investment (FPI) into India remained under pressure, recording net outflows of $8.9 billion during April-September, compared with $3 billion in the corresponding period of 2025. September alone accounted for $6.5 billion in outflows.


Speaking to Wealth Pakistan, Usama Rauf, investment analyst at AKD Securities, said the divergence between direct and portfolio investment was significant because the two forms of capital responded to different economic and financial conditions.


“FDI usually reflects longer-term decisions around manufacturing, services, technology and market access, while portfolio flows can reverse quickly when global yields, exchange-rate expectations or risk sentiment change,” he said.


“The improvement in direct investment is therefore constructive, but the durability of the broader recovery will depend on whether portfolio investors also regain confidence and whether new FDI continues beyond a few strong months.”


The RBI's October monetary policy statement had already highlighted the improvement in net FDI, reporting inflows of $13.8 billion during April-August 2026, compared with $9.6 billion a year earlier.


The central bank attributed the improvement to stronger gross inflows and slower growth in outward FDI. However, it also reported foreign portfolio outflows of $10.3 billion from April 1 to October 5, underscoring the contrasting trends in long-term investment and market-based capital.


Despite the volatility in portfolio flows, India's external position continues to provide a financial buffer. According to the RBI, foreign-exchange reserves covered approximately 11 months of imports and 94.4% of external debt, reducing immediate vulnerability to fluctuations in foreign capital flows.


Menka Kirpalani, investment analyst at Arif Habib Limited, told Wealth Pakistan that the sustainability of India's investment recovery would depend on whether foreign inflows became more diversified across sectors and remained resilient during periods of global financial uncertainty.


“A durable investment cycle requires more than a temporary increase in gross inflows. Investors look for earnings visibility, policy consistency, currency stability and confidence that capital can be deployed and repatriated efficiently,” she said.


Kirpalani noted that the September reversal demonstrated why improvements in headline investment figures should be interpreted cautiously.


“When FDI improves while portfolio investors are still withdrawing capital, it suggests confidence is not uniform across investor classes. Long-term investors may still see structural opportunities, but financial-market investors are more sensitive to valuations, global interest rates and near-term returns.”


The RBI's latest international investment position data also illustrate the scale of foreign capital exposure in India's economy.


At the end of June 2026, India's foreign liabilities stood at $1.433 trillion, including $560.9 billion in direct-investment liabilities and $224 billion in portfolio-investment liabilities.


The central bank reported that external liabilities increased by $11.6 billion during the June quarter, mainly because direct-investment liabilities rose by $15.7 billion, even as portfolio equity liabilities declined by $14 billion.


These contrasting movements further highlight the different trends affecting strategic investment and financial-market capital.


Rauf said the divergence between direct and portfolio investment could continue if global financial conditions remained volatile.


“The stronger FDI trend shows India can still attract strategic capital, but a full recovery in foreign investment would require both direct and portfolio channels to stabilise. Until then, the rebound should be viewed as encouraging but incomplete.”


India's latest investment figures therefore point to an uneven recovery, with longer-term capital showing improvement while foreign portfolio investors remain cautious.


The key test for 2027 will be whether direct investment maintains its momentum and portfolio outflows moderate, allowing the improvement in foreign capital flows to become broader and more sustainable.