
By Ayesha Saba
ISLAMABAD, Nov. 17 (INP-Wealth Pakistan) -- India's services sector recorded 10% year-on-year growth during April–June 2026, but the urban employment-to-population ratio showed little change in the following quarter, highlighting a persistent imbalance between economic expansion and job creation.
According to the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, real gross value added (GVA) in the services sector increased by 10%, compared with 8% a year earlier. Financial, real estate, information technology and professional services recorded stronger growth of 12.1%, while the overall economy expanded by 7.8%.
However, the latest Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS) showed that the urban worker-population ratio among people aged 15 and above stood at 46.9% during July–September 2026, virtually unchanged from 46.8% in the preceding quarter. The urban unemployment rate also edged up from 6.7% to 6.8%.
The figures highlight the challenge of translating strong services-sector growth into broad-based employment gains, particularly as expansion in high-productivity industries does not necessarily generate jobs at the same pace as economic output.
The structural imbalance was also highlighted in an October 2025 study by Indian government think tank NITI Aayog. According to its findings, services contributed nearly 55% of India's gross value added in 2024–25 but accounted for only 29.7% of total employment in 2023–24.
The sector's share of total employment had increased only marginally from 26.9% in 2011–12, despite a substantial rise in the absolute number of workers employed in services.
NITI Aayog estimated that services employment increased from 148 million workers in 2017–18 to 188 million in 2023–24, representing a net addition of 40 million jobs over six years.
However, the sector's employment share had peaked at 32.4% in 2018–19 before declining to 29.7% in 2023–24, indicating that its growing contribution to economic output had not consistently translated into a larger share of total employment.
The latest quarterly figures provide further context for this longstanding challenge. While services output expanded at a faster pace, the broader urban employment ratio remained largely unchanged.
Although the urban worker-population ratio covers employment across all sectors rather than services alone, the contrast raises questions about how effectively services-led growth is translating into wider labour-market opportunities.
Speaking to Wealth Pakistan, Amtul Hafeez, labour economist and assistant professor at the National University of Modern Languages (NUML), Islamabad, said India's services-sector performance highlighted the difficulty of translating economic expansion into sustainable employment, particularly when growth was concentrated in high-productivity industries with relatively limited labour requirements.
She said economic growth was increasingly concentrated in a limited number of large businesses, while its benefits were not reaching the wider workforce through sufficient employment opportunities.
According to Hafeez, such a pattern could result in an economy where headline growth remained strong but employment benefits were unevenly distributed across income groups and regions.
She noted that the expansion of large technology and financial-services companies did not necessarily improve employment prospects for workers in smaller cities or those entering the labour market without specialised qualifications.
This created a particular challenge for economies seeking to accommodate growing numbers of young workers while maintaining strong economic growth.
Hafeez suggested that policymakers should place greater emphasis on employment-intensive service industries, including logistics, tourism, healthcare, retail and business-support services.
She said targeted investment in these industries could generate employment opportunities across different skill levels and help distribute the benefits of economic expansion more widely.
“Governments should link investment incentives with measurable employment outcomes rather than focusing exclusively on output growth. Tax concessions, financing facilities and business-development programmes could be designed to encourage enterprises to create stable jobs, expand operations into smaller cities and improve working conditions,” she recommended.
Hafeez said employment outcomes should be assessed alongside economic growth indicators to determine whether expanding services activity was generating meaningful improvements in labour-market conditions.
Such an approach, she explained, could provide a clearer picture of whether services-sector expansion was creating sustainable jobs rather than simply increasing economic output.
She also highlighted the importance of improving access to employment for workers without specialised qualifications, particularly in smaller urban centres where opportunities in advanced technology and financial services might be limited.
The employment challenge carries implications for other developing economies seeking to expand their services sectors as a source of economic growth and export earnings.
For Pakistan, Hafeez suggested that policymakers should set measurable employment targets alongside services export targets to ensure that sectoral growth translated into broader economic benefits.
She said policies should prioritise technical training, women's labour-force participation and support for small enterprises to strengthen employment generation across different segments of the services economy.
India's experience illustrates the distinction between rapid growth in services output and the creation of broad-based employment opportunities.
While the sector has added millions of workers over the past several years, its share of total employment remains substantially below its contribution to national economic output.
The latest figures reinforce the importance of examining employment quality, workforce participation and the distribution of job opportunities alongside headline growth rates when assessing the economic benefits of services-sector expansion.