Image for: India's tax rethink highlights challenge of retaining foreign capital

 

By Azam Tariq


ISLAMABAD, Nov 14 (INP-Wealth Pakistan) -- India's consideration of tax relief for foreign equity investors following substantial portfolio outflows has highlighted the growing challenge of retaining international capital. Financial experts warned that competitive taxation alone cannot offset concerns over corporate earnings, currency stability and economic fundamentals.


Foreign investors had sold around $31 billion worth of Indian equities by early November 2026, although investment flows have since shown a sharp reversal, with overseas investors returning as net buyers during the month.


India's market regulator has recommended tax relief for foreign equity investors as the country seeks to improve its competitiveness against other emerging markets. The recommendation follows an earlier government decision to exempt eligible foreign investors from tax on interest income and capital gains from government securities.


Foreign portfolio investors withdrew Rs34,843 crore from Indian equities in October, following another substantial outflow in September. However, buying resumed towards the end of October and strengthened in November, indicating renewed interest among international investors.


Under India's existing tax framework, capital gains on specified listed equity securities held for more than one year are generally taxed at 12.5%, while applicable short-term gains on such securities are taxed at 20%, subject to prescribed conditions.


Speaking to Wealth Pakistan, Madhavi Arora, Chief Economist at Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd., said capital-gains taxation is a critical factor for international investors, as global funds evaluate investment destinations on the basis of post-tax returns.


However, she cautioned against attributing India's sustained foreign portfolio outflows primarily to taxation.


“Taxation is an important consideration, but it is unlikely to be the principal determinant of portfolio allocation decisions,” she said.


Arora explained that foreign investors ultimately assessed markets on the basis of risk-adjusted and currency-adjusted returns rather than taxation alone.


In India's case, relatively high equity valuations, moderating corporate earnings growth, alternative investment opportunities in other emerging markets and rupee depreciation have collectively reduced the relative attractiveness of Indian equities.


She said India's earlier advantage in corporate earnings growth had narrowed compared with some competing Asian markets, while its equities continued to trade at a valuation premium.


This has made markets such as South Korea increasingly competitive for international investors seeking stronger earnings momentum and exposure to major global investment themes.


Currency movements had also become an important consideration, she said, because depreciation of the Indian rupee could reduce equity gains when investment returns were converted into US dollars.


Against this backdrop, Arora said rationalising long-term capital-gains taxation could improve India's investment competitiveness by increasing post-tax returns and reducing disadvantages relative to competing markets.


However, she emphasised that tax relief should be treated as a facilitating measure rather than a standalone solution to foreign portfolio outflows.


“Sustainable foreign investor participation will depend much more on an improvement in underlying earnings delivery, more reasonable valuations and stable macroeconomic fundamentals,” she said.


Arora said a broader strategy for attracting and retaining international investors should combine tax predictability with stronger private investment, consumption, infrastructure spending and productivity-enhancing reforms.


Such measures, she explained, would help improve corporate earnings and strengthen the underlying investment case for Indian equities.


She also highlighted currency stability, adequate foreign-exchange buffers, fiscal credibility, price stability and a manageable current-account deficit as important factors influencing international investor confidence.


According to Arora, foreign portfolio investment decisions are shaped by the overall economic environment, making consistent macroeconomic management essential for sustaining capital inflows.


India's experience also carries implications for Pakistan and other frontier markets seeking to attract international portfolio investment amid growing competition for global capital.


Speaking to Wealth Pakistan, Waqas Ghani, Head of Equity Research at JS Global Capital Ltd., said competitive taxation could improve post-tax investment returns and make Pakistan relatively more attractive compared with other emerging and frontier markets.


However, he stressed that tax incentives alone were insufficient to ensure sustained foreign investment.


“Nevertheless, tax incentives alone cannot compensate for currency uncertainty or concerns around the sustainability of economic policies,” he said.
Ghani described taxation as an important but secondary consideration in international portfolio allocation decisions.


He explained that retaining foreign investors required a consistent and competitive investment environment because global funds could readily shift capital between markets in response to changing economic conditions and investment opportunities.


As a result, emerging and frontier markets competed not only on economic growth prospects and equity valuations but also on regulatory predictability, taxation, transaction costs, market liquidity and ease of access.


Ghani said a predictable investment framework was particularly important for countries seeking to build long-term confidence among international portfolio investors.


His observations reinforced the broader argument that while lower taxes could improve a market's relative attractiveness, foreign investment decisions ultimately depended on the sustainability of economic policies and the ability of businesses to generate competitive returns.


For India, the debate over capital-gains taxation comes at a time when international investors are reassessing equity markets on the basis of earnings prospects, valuations and currency risks.


Although proposed tax relief could reduce investment costs and improve post-tax returns, analysts believe that sustained foreign participation will depend more fundamentally on stronger corporate earnings, stable macroeconomic conditions and a predictable regulatory environment.


The experience highlights a wider challenge for emerging and frontier economies: attracting foreign portfolio capital through competitive taxation may be relatively straightforward, but retaining it requires consistent economic policies, investor confidence and investment opportunities capable of delivering sustainable returns.